10 Questions to Ask a Roofer for a Roofing Insurance Claim

Hiring the right contractor for your roofing insurance claim can mean the difference between a quick, stress-free repair or delays, denials, and out-of-pocket surprises. At 5 Coat Roofing & Construction, we’ve helped hundreds of homeowners navigate insurance claims after storm damage, and we know exactly what red flags to watch for.

Before you sign any contract, ask these 10 essential questions to ensure your roofer can handle both the repairs and the insurance process with skill and integrity.

Key Takeaways

  • Choosing the right contractor is critical to the success of your roofing insurance claim, don’t rush the decision.
  • Ask about licensing, insurance experience, timelines, warranties, and how they handle communication with insurance adjusters.
  • Look for transparency and trustworthiness. If a contractor avoids questions or gives vague answers, that’s a red flag.
  • A contractor experienced in insurance claims can help you avoid delays, underpayments, or denied claims.
  • Always get everything in writing, including estimates, scopes of work, and agreements with your insurer.
  • Your roof protects your home; make sure the person fixing it knows how to protect your claim too.

roofing insurance claim by roofer

Before You Hire a Roofing Contractor for an Insurance Claim

When your roof is damaged, and an insurance claim is involved, choosing the right contractor is more than just comparing prices. It’s about protecting your home, your finances, and your peace of mind. The contractor you hire should not only deliver high-quality repairs but also be well-versed in the insurance claims process, helping you avoid unnecessary delays, denials, or out-of-pocket costs.

At 5Coat Roofing & Construction, we’ve worked with hundreds of homeowners just like you, navigating insurance paperwork, meeting with adjusters, and ensuring every shingle and service is covered correctly. To help you make a confident, informed decision, we’ve compiled 10 essential questions you should ask any roofing contractor before hiring them for your insurance restoration project.

These questions are designed to:

  • Uncover red flags before it’s too late
  • Help you compare contractors more effectively
  • Ensure your roofer understands how to protect your claim as well as your roof

1. Are You Licensed and Insured?

  • Why It Matters: Ensuring that your roofing contractor is licensed and insured is vital for your protection. A licensed contractor meets local regulations and standards, while insurance coverage protects you from potential liabilities during the repair process. At 5Coat Roofing & Construction, we are fully licensed and insured, providing you with peace of mind and professional assurance.

2. What Is Your Experience with Insurance Claims?

  • Why It Matters: Contractors experienced in handling insurance claims can simplify the process and facilitate smoother communication with your insurance company. At 5Coat Roofing & Construction, we have extensive experience working with insurance companies and can guide you through every step of the claims process, ensuring that your repairs are covered effectively.

3. Can You Provide References from Previous Clients?

  • Why It Matters: References and reviews are essential for assessing a contractor’s reliability and quality of work. We at 5Coat Roofing & Construction are proud of our track record and can provide references and testimonials from satisfied clients who have benefited from our top-notch roofing and insurance restoration services.

4. What Is the Scope of the Work and the Timeline for Completion?

  • Why It Matters: Understanding the full scope of the work and a clear timeline helps manage expectations and ensures that all necessary repairs are covered. We provide detailed written estimates and project timelines at 5Coat Roofing & Construction, ensuring transparency and keeping you informed throughout the process.

5. What Type of Warranty Do You Offer?

  • Why It Matters: A robust warranty provides protection against future issues with workmanship or materials. 5Coat Roofing & Construction offers comprehensive warranties on both our workmanship and the materials we use, including the GAF Silver Pledge Limited Warranty, which provides long-term coverage and peace of mind.

6. How Will You Handle the Insurance Claim Process?

  • Why It Matters: A clear process for handling insurance claims can prevent delays and misunderstandings. At 5Coat Roofing & Construction, we work closely with your insurance company to manage documentation, inspections, and claims, ensuring a smooth and efficient process.

7. Are There Any Additional Costs or Fees?

  • Why It Matters: Clarifying any potential additional costs helps avoid surprises. Our detailed estimates at 5Coat Roofing & Construction outline all anticipated costs, including any potential extra charges, ensuring that you have a clear understanding of the financial aspects of your project.

8. How Do You Handle Unexpected Repairs or Issues?

  • Why It Matters: Unforeseen issues can arise during repairs. Knowing how a contractor handles these situations helps you plan accordingly. At 5Coat Roofing & Construction, we address unexpected issues transparently and professionally, providing solutions and adjustments as needed to ensure your project stays on track.

9. What Materials and Products Will You Use?

  • Why It Matters: The quality of materials impacts the durability of your roof. We use high-quality materials from trusted manufacturers at 5Coat Roofing & Construction, ensuring that your roof repair or replacement meets industry standards and is backed by strong warranties.

10. Do You Offer a Written Contract?

  • Why It Matters: A written contract protects both you and the contractor by clearly defining the project terms. 5Coat Roofing & Construction provides a comprehensive written contract for every project, outlining scope, costs, and timelines, and ensuring that all parties are aligned.

Conclusion: Protect Your Roof, and Your Insurance Claim

Choosing the right roofing contractor isn’t just about fixing your roof. It’s about protecting your home, your finances, and the success of your insurance claim. By asking the right questions up front, you ensure you’re hiring someone who’s not only skilled in roofing but experienced in navigating the insurance process with confidence and transparency.

At 5Coat Roofing & Construction, we specialize in insurance restoration projects. From the initial inspection to completion, we guide you through every step, coordinating with your adjuster, documenting damage properly, and making sure no coverage is left on the table. Our team is fully licensed, insured, and backed by a reputation built on trust, quality workmanship, and real results for homeowners just like you.

Schedule your free, no-obligation inspection today and let’s make sure your insurance claim works for you, not against you.

Book Your Consultation Now. We’re here to help you get your home back to top shape, with zero guesswork and full peace of mind.

FAQS

How old can a roof be before insurance considers it “too old”?

There’s no universal age limit, but many insurance companies begin reducing coverage once a roof is 15–20 years old, especially for asphalt shingles. Older roofs are often covered at actual cash value (ACV) instead of replacement cost, depending on your policy.

What should you avoid saying to a roof insurance adjuster?

Avoid guessing the cause of damage, admitting fault, or saying the roof was already failing. Stick to the facts, describe what you see, and let a qualified roofing contractor help document storm-related damage accurately.

What types of roof damage are typically covered by insurance?

Most policies cover sudden, accidental damage caused by events like hail, wind, falling debris, or severe storms. Damage from wear and tear, lack of maintenance, or age-related deterioration is usually not covered.

Is it worth filing an insurance claim for roof damage?

It often is, especially if storm damage affects the roof’s integrity or could lead to leaks and interior damage. A professional roof inspection can help determine whether the damage justifies a claim and if the potential payout outweighs your deductible.

Recent Articles